college football playoff rankings part two

Last week I was going to do another write up for my playoff rankings using my formula. But after inputting the numbers in my spreadsheet, three loss Ohio State was still in the top 5. So, I spent the last few days adjusting the numbers. And while I believe that OSU still has a spot in my top ten, I do feel like that is justified due to who they’ve beaten and lost to.

In the previous iteration of my formula, I didn’t take points away for losses. I took points away for what I deem a bad loss, but not regular losses. Now, I take away points from a loss and even more points for a bad loss.

College Football Playoff Rankings

Rank Team Points
1 Utah Utes 236
2 UCLA Bruins 226
3 Texas Longhorns 222
4 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 218
5 BYU Cougars 215
6 Miami Hurricanes 214
7 Georgia Bulldogs 213
8 Ohio State Buckeyes 209
9 Texas Tech Red Raiders 204
10 Indiana Hoosiers 201
11 Oregon Ducks 197
12 Tennessee Volunteers 195
13 USC Trojans 193
14 Alabama Crimson Tide 190
15 Wake Forest Demon Deacons 188

With my formula, ranked wins and strength of schedule mean A LOT. Number one Utah and number two UCLA have big ranked wins that help their cause. Utah have the wins against Houston, BYU and Arizona. While UCLA has the victory over Oregon. There is less than a ten point gap in-between number four Notre Dame and number eight Ohio State. Why is three loss Ohio State in my top ten? Comes down to the combined wins of their opponents; AKA strength of schedule. Their opponents have 72 combined victories, which is second in the FBS, right behind USC. So, why is Ohio State so far above USC when USC is first in SoS? The Trojans have one big victory, which comes against Ohio State. But OSU has those two big wins against Indiana and Iowa.

The coach of Indiana, Curt Cignetti has made waves the last week because he is upset at his team’s place in the CFP rankings. The numbers don’t lie folks. They have one signature win against USC that doesn’t really look that impressive. Their SoS isn’t that good. They beat a Nebraska team that, while they were undefeated when they played each other, are just 1-3 since then. These are the wins that they have against the conference opponents they’ve had.

Northwestern 6-4

Rutgers 2-8

Michigan 5-5

Minnesota 5-5

And only the win against Rutgers was a blowout. Ironically enough, if they had beat Ohio State, OSU would have 4 losses and that win would be just another victory as well.

Recently ESPN announced that they are moving to a 24 team playoff next year. We all know that it’s a money grab. And I’ve seen other people state that it will ruin conferences. They are reportedly doing away with conference championships with this news. I feel like getting rid of the conference championships is a detriment to the sport. Championship games are exciting. Not just for the fans but the players as well. Those players that don’t have NFL aspirations get to experience what it’s like to play for something bigger than just a regular game.

I’ve seen it mentioned that if they do away with conference championships, they may as well do away with conferences in general. That more teams should adopt the Notre Dame way of staying independent. I don’t think that any team should go that far. Conferences will still mean something, even if you can no longer win that championship.

Ultimately though, this concept only works if they let some Cinderellas in the playoffs. This year alone, the teams that sit with really good records that don’t meet the criteria a lot of formulas use are:

Liberty: 9-1

UTSA: 8-2

North Dakota State: 8-2

James Madison: 8-3

Air Force: 8-2

Louisiana Tech: 8-2

I’m not suggesting that every one of these teams should be in the playoffs. They probably shouldn’t be in the playoffs in place of some seven win teams. But how cool would it be to see one of these teams take down one of the “blue bloods”? What if 24th ranked Air Force beat 9th ranked Texas Tech? Or anything similar. Cinderella stories is what made March Madness so successful. Especially from the late 90’s until a few years ago before NIL ruined college sports. Just to clarify, I do believe that college players should get paid. I just think that a better system could have been used. College sports have become pay to win. I mean, in a lot of instances it already was. But you know what I mean. Those scrappy underdogs don’t have much of a chance any longer.

There is only one game between ranked opponents this week as #1 Georgia takes on #21 South Carolina. I would have said to look out for South Carolina to pull the upset this week. But they just lost to Arkansas badly. Every ranked team is pretty much involved in a cupcake week. I could see Nebraska making life a bit difficult for Ohio State. West Virginia could play #20 Houston a lot better than people think. And of course, there is LSU versus #9 Tennessee.

Next
Next

my college football playoff rankings